Learning Objectives
- Differentiate a relation while treating y as a function of x locally.
- Solve for dy/dx after applying chain and product rules.
- Find a tangent slope at a point and recognize where the derivative formula fails.
Prerequisites: the chain rule, product rule, and tangent-line equations. Implicit differentiation is useful when x and y are linked by an equation that is inconvenient to solve explicitly for y.
1. Differentiate Both Sides with Respect to x
When y depends on x, differentiating y² requires the chain rule: d(y²)/dx = 2y(dy/dx). Write y′ for dy/dx if convenient. In contrast, d(x²)/dx = 2x because the derivative of x with respect to itself is 1.
Worked Example: A Circle
Differentiate x² + y² = 25. The result is 2x + 2yy′ = 0.
Solve for y′: 2yy′ = −2x, so y′ = −x/y wherever y ≠ 0 on a differentiable local branch.
At the point (3, 4), the slope is −3/4. The tangent line is y − 4 = (−3/4)(x − 3). The point satisfies the original relation because 9 + 16 = 25.
2. A Product Involving y Needs Both Rules
For the product xy, both factors depend on x: the first directly, the second through y(x). Therefore d(xy)/dx = y + xy′. Differentiating it as just y or just xy′ misses one term.
Worked Example: Collect the Derivative Terms
For x² + xy + y² = 7, differentiate to obtain 2x + y + xy′ + 2yy′ = 0.
Collect terms containing y′: (x + 2y)y′ = −(2x + y). Thus y′ = −(2x + y)/(x + 2y), when x + 2y ≠ 0.
At (1, 2), the relation holds because 1 + 2 + 4 = 7. The slope is −4/5, so the tangent line is y − 2 = (−4/5)(x − 1).
3. Check That the Point Lies on the Curve
A derivative expression may accept a numerical pair that is not on the original relation, but the resulting number would not be a tangent slope to that curve at that point. Substitute the point into the original equation before reporting a tangent line.
4. Zero Denominators Need Geometric Analysis
For the circle x² + y² = 25, the formula −x/y fails when y = 0. At (5, 0) and (−5, 0), the tangent lines are vertical, x = 5 and x = −5, so there is no finite derivative dy/dx there.
A zero denominator in an implicit derivative does not always prove a vertical tangent by itself. If both numerator and denominator vanish, the relation may have a more complicated local shape. Check the original curve rather than dividing by zero or assigning a slope without justification.
5. Differentiate Again Carefully
Example: A Second Derivative on the Circle
Starting from y′ = −x/y, apply the quotient rule: y″ = [−y + xy′]/y².
Substitute y′ = −x/y to get y″ = −(x² + y²)/y³. On the circle, x² + y² = 25, so y″ = −25/y³ where y ≠ 0.
At (3, 4), the second derivative is −25/64. Even when a formula contains y, it is still differentiated as a function of x.
Common Mistakes
- Attach y′ when differentiating a nonconstant function of y with respect to x.
- Use the product rule for terms such as xy.
- Solve for y′ only after collecting every term that contains it.
- Check the point and any denominator restrictions before substitution.
6. Practice
- Find dy/dx for x² + 4y² = 16.
- Find the tangent line to that ellipse at (0, 2).
- Find dy/dx for xy = 6 and evaluate it at (2, 3).
- Differentiate sin y = x² implicitly on a differentiable branch where cos y ≠ 0.
Worked Solutions
- Differentiation gives 2x + 8yy′ = 0, so y′ = −x/(4y) when y ≠ 0.
- The point lies on the ellipse and the slope is 0. The tangent line is y = 2.
- The product rule gives y + xy′ = 0, so y′ = −y/x for x ≠ 0. At (2, 3), the slope is −3/2.
- The chain rule gives (cos y)y′ = 2x, so y′ = 2x/cos y under the stated condition.
7. Summary
- Treat y as depending on x during implicit differentiation.
- Combine chain and product rules, then isolate y′.
- A tangent calculation requires a point on the original relation.
- Analyze exceptional points separately when the solved formula has a zero denominator.